Source # | 18152 |
Entered by | Matt Vernon |
Checksums | d1 |
Disc Counts | 1 / 1 |
Media Size | |
Date Circulated
Date Added |
06/17/2003 06/28/2003 |
Other Sources (comments) 30 minute jam; See info... (0) Jerry Garcia, Harvey Mandel... (0) Garcia, Harvey Mandel &... (0) Garcia, Bishop, Mandel,... (0) "Harvey Mandel Band w/... (3) |
|||
Date | User | Comment | |
---|---|---|---|
07/07/2003 | Aaron Rumack | This should really be under Garcia. One man does not make the Grateful Dead. Just one man's opinion. | |
07/08/2003 | Matt Vernon |
There is a shn set for this under Garcia http://db.etree.org/shninfo_detail.php?shnid=15051 |
|
07/08/2003 | Aaron Rumack | Thanks Matt but it is not the same source(SHN set) | |
07/09/2003 | Matt Vernon | I think all I said was there is A shn set under Garcia for this date, not THIS particular shn set. To address your comment more directly this date and a few others are listed under the Grateful Dead because someone placed them there before Garcia and other Jerry projects were started. To change this is a major hassle because all the people that have it on their list must be "unlinked" before it can be deleted and there are only a few people that have these "super user" powers. The best thing would be to enter this and other shn sets for this date on the Garcia shns-in-circ list and encourage people to unlink themselves from this and relink to the shns/date on Garcia. Hope this helps... | |
07/09/2003 | Diana |
If it's circulating (albeit falsely?) under Mickey and the Hartbeats, it might as well stay here too, since Hartbeats stuff has been historically listed under this section (as is "Seastones"). Those artist names are softlinked to this GD shn section. I suppose someone could submit these same ones to Garcia section, with url crossrefs added in the comments box as appropriate. It's not the maximally tidy solution, but it's in the same general category as having source info duplicated on dates "2/12/70" and 2/13/70 because of the Ungano confusion. Or having source info soundcheck duplicated on "2/24/74" vs. 2/22/74. ;) |
|
07/09/2003 | Joe Jupille | I'd also just add that putting it under 'Garcia', while perhaps slightly more accurate, doesn't seem that much better. I mean, why not list it under 'Harvey Mandel'? ;-) | |
07/09/2003 | Sorry Matt, I misunderstood your post. I didn't realize the impact of changing the source to 'Garcia'. It was just a thought as I was adding it to my list. I understand the linkage with Grateful Dead, but I thought it would be more accurate to list it under Garcia. Didn't mean to ruffle any feathers. Thank you all for what you do. | ||
07/09/2003 | Matt Vernon | No feathers ruffled here - I just wanted to say that currently different shn sets for this performance are being listed in two locations here on db.etree.org, here AND under Garcia. Also, Joe's comment is important as this isn't really a Hartbeat's show. If I had to suggest a place where these shn's should reside, I would file it under Garcia as my guess is the majority of people with this shn set have it because of the Garcia connection and would look for it there first (since there is no Harvey Mandel shn admin as far as I know...) | |
07/11/2003 | Ziggy | Is Harvey Mandel the dude who played the solo in "Concrete Jungle"? That's awesome. He jammed with Jerry, huh? |